⏰ Town of Tonawanda: Grievance Day in Tonawanda is the 4th Tuesday in May — a hard deadline with no extensions. Don't miss your window to challenge an excessive assessment.
Town of Tonawanda · Erie County · Assessment Challenges

Is Your Tonawanda
Property Assessment
Excessive?

The Town of Tonawanda stretches from Kenmore and the Delaware and Elmwood corridors to the industrial riverfront along the Niagara. Many owners — residential and industrial alike — carry assessments that don't reflect actual market conditions or property condition.

An assessment is an opinion, not a final number. Duffy & Catlin PLLC represents commercial, industrial, and residential owners across Tonawanda and Erie County in challenging assessments that don't hold up — at no upfront cost.

Serving Tonawanda, all of Erie County, and New York State · No fee unless we achieve a reduction · Attorney advertising · Duffy & Catlin PLLC.

📅  Tonawanda & Erie County — Key 2026 Dates
Grievance Day
⚠ 4th Tuesday in May Tonawanda hears assessment grievances on Grievance Day. Miss it and you wait a full year.
~ May 1
Tentative Roll Filed The tentative assessment roll is typically published around May 1 — review it as soon as it's out.
Summer 2026
School Tax Bills Issued District bills reflect the new assessed values and arrive in late summer.
Jan 2027
Erie County Bills Issued County and town bills are mailed in January — reductions apply here too.
Get a Free Tonawanda Assessment Review →
Why Tonawanda Owners Are Seeing Increases

How Tonawanda Values Your Property — and Where It Goes Wrong

When Town of Tonawanda builds its assessment roll, properties are valued in bulk using broad market models. Those models lean on neighborhood-wide trends — not your building's condition, your block, your actual rent roll, or the most relevant comparable sales.

Tonawanda pairs dense, walkable neighborhoods around Kenmore with a heavy industrial riverfront — legacy chemical, energy, and manufacturing sites along the Niagara River. Functional obsolescence and environmental factors make industrial over-assessment common, and mass models rarely capture them. Towns hear grievances only on Grievance Day, the 4th Tuesday in May.

  • Income-producing properties have distinct valuation standards the assessor is required to apply
  • Vacancy, below-market leases, and deferred maintenance are all recognized grounds for challenge
  • Older and industrial properties often carry functional obsolescence that mass models overlook
  • You are not required to accept the town's opinion of value as final
Review My Tonawanda Assessment →
What's at stake
$0
Upfront cost. We work on contingency — a fee applies only if we win a reduction. The Tonawanda case review is always free.
1×
Per year. There is one formal window to grieve your Tonawanda assessment. Miss it and you wait a full cycle.
Erie
County-wide. We file across Tonawanda and the Erie County suburbs — Amherst, Grand Island, Buffalo, and beyond.
All
Property types. Commercial, industrial, mixed-use, multi-family, and residential.
Who We Represent in Tonawanda

Commercial, Industrial & Residential Challenges Across the Town

Commercial and industrial properties are especially vulnerable to over-assessment in a mass revaluation. The income, cost, and sales-comparison approaches each require proper application — and a mass model doesn't always get Tonawanda right.

🏢

Commercial & Office

Kenmore retail, Sheridan Drive and Delaware storefronts, and mixed-use buildings are frequently assessed without proper regard for real vacancy, lease terms, or market income. We apply the correct methodology to challenge inflated values.

Kenmore retail Sheridan Drive Mixed-use Storefronts
🏭

Industrial & Warehouse

Riverfront manufacturing, energy and utility sites, and warehouses along the Niagara carry functional obsolescence and environmental factors that mass appraisals routinely miss.

Riverfront industrial Manufacturing Warehouses Energy / utility
🏠

Residential & Multi-Family

Homes, doubles, and multi-family in Kenmore, Brighton, and Sheridan Parkside all benefit from review. Even modest increases compound into real tax liability over an assessment cycle.

Single-family Doubles Multi-family Investment property
Hidden Tax Increases

Even a Flat Assessment Can Cost You More

New York calculates an equalization rate for every municipality — the ratio of assessed value to full market value. When Tonawanda and Erie County market prices rise faster than assessments are updated, that rate falls, and the State treats your property as worth more for purposes of county tax apportionment.

The result is a larger share of the Erie County levy landing on your bill — with no change to the assessment roll and no formal notice. If your assessment was already excessive, the compounding effect is even greater. A timely challenge corrects both problems at once.

Request a Free Review →
$0
Upfront. Contingency fee — you pay only if we achieve a reduction.
1×
Per year. There is a single formal window to challenge your Tonawanda assessment.
Erie
County-wide practice across Tonawanda and Erie County.
All
Property types — commercial, industrial, mixed-use, multi-family, and residential.
Time-Sensitive

How a Tonawanda Challenge Works

Step 1

Free Case Review

Send us your assessment notice. We evaluate whether your Tonawanda property has been over-assessed and advise you honestly on the strength of a challenge — at no cost and no obligation.

Act Early
Step 2

Informal Review

Tonawanda's assessor often allows a brief period to engage before the formal deadline. Early contact gives us the most time to build a complete, well-supported case.

Hard Deadline
Step 3

File on Grievance Day

We file your grievance with the Tonawanda Board of Assessment Review on Grievance Day — the 4th Tuesday in May. Miss it and you wait a full year, so we track the date and prepare well ahead.

Step 4

Hearing & Tax Relief

We represent you at every hearing. Approved reductions appear on your school tax bill in late summer and your Erie County bill issued the following January.

Our Approach

Handled Entirely by Our Attorneys

From the first case review to any formal hearing or court proceeding, we manage every step of your Tonawanda appeal — so you don't have to.

01

Free Consultation

Call or submit the form. We review your Tonawanda assessment notice and tell you honestly whether the evidence supports a viable challenge — no cost, no obligation.

02

Analysis & Evidence

For commercial property we examine income data, local comparables, cost approaches, and property-specific conditions to build a documented, credible case for reduction.

03

We Handle All Filings

We prepare and submit every document — informal review applications, Town of Tonawanda BAR petitions, and supporting exhibits — correctly and before every deadline.

04

Full Representation

We manage all communication with the assessor's office and appear on your behalf at any BAR hearing, SCAR proceeding, or Article 7 court case. You stay informed without attending.

Where We File

Tonawanda Areas & Erie County Towns

Town of Tonawanda

Kenmore Sheridan Parkside Brighton Riverfront Industrial Lincoln Park Town Line

Erie County & Nearby

Amherst Buffalo Grand Island City of Tonawanda Kenmore Cheektowaga

Don't see your municipality? We file across all of New York State. If you own property anywhere in the region — city or town, commercial or residential — contact us and we'll confirm the correct deadline and process for your location.

Common Questions

Tonawanda Property Owners Ask

When is the deadline to challenge my Tonawanda assessment? +
Town grievances in New York are heard on Grievance Day — the 4th Tuesday in May — after the tentative assessment roll is published, typically around May 1. The Town of Tonawanda follows this schedule. The window is brief and unforgiving once it passes, so the safest step is to contact us as soon as the tentative roll is out (or earlier) so we can review your assessment and file in time.
If my assessment went up, does that mean my taxes are going up? +
A higher assessed value doesn't automatically raise your bill — it depends on your assessment relative to other Tonawanda properties and the applicable tax rates. But a significantly elevated value can translate into a real increase in town, county, and school taxes, especially for commercial and industrial property. We can review your specific notice and explain what it means for you.
Do you handle properties outside Town of Tonawanda? +
Yes. We represent owners throughout Erie County — Amherst, Buffalo, Grand Island and beyond — and across all of New York State. Town properties follow the standard Grievance Day schedule, while cities use their own charter deadlines. We track the correct one for your municipality.
What does it cost to have Duffy & Catlin PLLC challenge my assessment? +
Nothing upfront. We work on a contingency basis — we only collect a fee if we achieve a reduction in your assessment. The initial consultation and case review are always free. There is no financial risk in having us evaluate your Tonawanda property.
What makes commercial challenges different from residential ones? +
Commercial valuation is considerably more involved. Income-producing properties are typically valued using an income-capitalization approach that accounts for vacancy, actual rents, operating expenses, and market cap rates. Mass reassessments frequently fail to apply these factors correctly, which is why commercial challenges often have strong evidentiary grounds.
What if my case isn't strong enough to challenge? +
We'll tell you that upfront — at no cost. We only pursue challenges where the evidence supports a meritorious case. Our credibility with the Tonawanda assessor and the Board of Assessment Review depends on bringing well-grounded, properly documented appeals.
How long does the process take? +
The informal review and Board of Assessment Review process typically runs through spring and early summer. Cases that proceed to SCAR or Article 7 court proceedings may take additional months. Throughout, our attorneys handle all communications and appearances on your behalf.
Get Started

Request a Free Tonawanda Case Evaluation

Tell us about your property. Whether you're in Tonawanda, the Erie County suburbs, or anywhere in New York State, we'll review your assessment and advise you honestly at no cost.

✅  Thank you — your inquiry has been received. A member of our team will be in touch within one business day.
⚠️  Something went wrong. Please try again, or call us directly at (716) 755-2125.

No obligation. No upfront fees. We typically respond within one business day. Attorney advertising.

(716) 755-2125

Duffy & Catlin PLLC
505 Ellicott Street, Suite 500
Buffalo, NY 14203

Serving Tonawanda & Erie County We represent owners throughout Tonawanda and the surrounding Erie County — from busy commercial corridors to established residential streets.
Contingency Fee — No Upfront Cost Our fee applies only if we achieve a reduction in your assessment. The initial review is always free.
Licensed New York Attorneys All work is performed by or under the supervision of licensed NY attorneys. We appear at every stage so you don't have to.
Act Before the Deadline Grievance Day is a hard deadline with no extensions. The earlier you reach out, the more time we have to build a thorough case.
Free Case Review
Tweaks
Header → hero spacing 84px
Section spacing 96px
Accent color